Hatred of Barbie
I don't believe that Dr Nairn is even close to interpreting these reactions correctly. Regarding something as not special and disposal doesn't normally lead to violent rejection. There are clearly other factors at play.Why little girls like to torture Barbie
By Nick Foley in London
IF you've caught your daughter mutilating her Barbie doll, microwaving her, or decapitating her, don't be disturbed - your girl is perfectly normal.
Research published yesterday reveals that as girls grow up, they come to hate Barbie so much that many admit torturing and maiming the doll. The toy has become a "hate figure" among seven to 11-year-old girls, who regard Barbie as a "babyish" symbol of their earlier childhood.
Researchers from the University of Bath questioned 100 youngsters about their attitudes to a range of branded products and found the iconic doll provoked the strongest reaction.
"When we asked the groups of junior school children about Barbie, the doll provoked rejection, hatred and violence," said Agnes Nairn, who led the study. "The meaning of Barbie went beyond an expressed antipathy; actual physical violence and torture towards the doll was repeatedly reported, quite gleefully, across age, school and gender."
Dr Nairn said: "It's as though disavowing Barbie is a rite of passage and a rejection of their past.
"The types of mutilation .. range from removing the hair to decapitation, burning, breaking and even microwaving."
The study also found that while boys expressed feelings of nostalgia towards Action Man, girls' attitude to Barbie was hostile.
"The girls almost always talked about having a box full of Barbies," Dr Nairn said. "So, to them, Barbie has come to symbolise excess. Barbies are not special, they are disposable, and are thrown away and rejected."
This is what I think is going on:
Barbie symbolizes womanly perfection in the minds of young girls. For years, they are able to dress her, brush her hair, place her in various situations - all the while revelling in the fantasies associated with being an attractive woman. It's a blissful girlie dream with very few demands or stresses.
However, when a girl begins to approach puberty, everything changes. What used to be an idle dream is now a very serious pursuit. The girl now has to factor her own self into the equation.
Now she is the one being judged, together with all her flaws and imperfections. Accordingly, Barbie changes from being a joyful symbol of womanly perfection to a harsh mirror which highlights the girl's flaws. Indeed, the very perfection and beauty of Barbie only serves to emphasize the girl's imperfections and ugliness. And so the girl violently pushes the Barbie away. She cannot stand the sight of her.
[edited url link for the sake of my own sanity - D.R.]
-
